Longer Out Than In

Longer Out Than In — the AI-made song and lyric film made from this essay (captions available). Watch on YouTube →

It usually starts somewhere ordinary. A checkout line. A bus that has stopped between stations. A meeting where nothing is wrong. The heart picks up for no reason anyone can see, then it pounds. The breath goes short and high, as if the room has less air in it than it did a minute ago. Hands tingle. The floor seems a little far away. And then comes the worst part, the thought that arrives with total certainty: something is very wrong, and I am about to die, or faint, or lose my mind, right here, in front of everyone.

Aisle seven, the cereal boxes leaning in
My heart’s a fist against a door
I’m sure I’m dying here between the oats and the coffee

That is what a panic attack can feel like from the inside. I want to write about it plainly, because a lot of people go through it alone and in silence, and many of them believe, for months or years, that they are the only one, or that it means they are breaking.

Here is the first thing worth knowing. Panic is your body’s alarm, going off at the wrong time. The same rush that would help you run from a fire floods in when there is no fire. The pounding heart, the quick breath, the shaking, the strange feeling that the world is far away: each one is part of that alarm. It is real. It is not imagined, and it is not weakness. It is also not the same as the danger it announces. A panic attack rises, peaks within minutes, and then eases, even when it feels like it will go on forever.

And the alarm don’t know there’s no fire
It just rings and rings

The second thing is harder to believe while it is happening: fighting it tends to feed it. The natural move is to clench, to try to force it to stop, to check your pulse again and again, to run. But adding fear to fear is like blowing on a fire. What often helps is the opposite of fighting. Name it, quietly, to yourself: this is panic, and it will pass. Then let the wave come up and go down.

And breathe out. Not in. Out. When panic comes the body gulps air, short and high in the chest, and it feels like there is not enough. Reaching for more only speeds it up. A long, slow breath out is how you slow it down. So in through the nose for about four, and out slowly for about six. Longer out than in. Do it again. Press your feet into the floor. Find five things you can see, and name them, even silently: a red sign, a crack in the tile, somebody’s blue scarf. Cold water on your wrists or face can help too. None of this is magic. It is a way of telling your body, in a language it understands, that you are not running from anything.

Now the part I will not leave out. Panic can feel very much like a heart attack, and only a doctor can tell them apart. If it is the first time, or it feels different from before, get checked. If there is chest pain or pressure, especially spreading to the arm, jaw or back, or breathing trouble that does not ease, or fainting, or weakness or numbness on one side, call 911. That is not overreacting. That is taking yourself seriously, and nobody at an emergency room will be sorry you came.

There is also the fear that comes after. Many people who have had one panic attack begin to arrange their lives around not having another. They stop taking the train. They leave the store with the cart half full. They sit near the door. The world gets a little smaller every month, and it happens so slowly that it can look like a preference instead of a cage. If that is happening to you, it is worth saying out loud to a doctor: this keeps coming back, and it is changing how I live. Panic is very treatable. Therapy helps many people, especially the kind called cognitive behavioral therapy, and medication helps some. You do not have to just live with it.

If you are the one beside someone when it hits, you have a simple job. Stay. Speak slowly. Do not tell them to calm down; they would if they could. Do not crowd them. You might say: I’m here, it’s panic, it passes, breathe out with me. Then breathe out, slow and long, where they can hear you, and let them borrow your rhythm. Sitting on a curb with someone for ten minutes is not nothing. It can be the thing they remember about the worst day of their year.

You didn’t say calm down, you didn’t crowd me
You breathed out slow where I could hear it
Till your rhythm was my own

And if it is too much, if under the panic there is a deeper feeling that you do not want to be here, call or text 988, any hour. A real person answers.

We built a small private page for these minutes at scarletbeast.com/panic. It has a breathing circle, words to hold onto, a card you can show someone when it is hard to talk, and a plan you can print. Nothing you tap there is sent anywhere. It cannot sit beside you on the curb. But it can breathe with you, slowly, as long as you need, longer out than in.

The song

“Longer Out Than In” is an early-1970s-style singer-songwriter song made from this essay, sung by a woman who has a panic attack in aisle seven of an ordinary grocery store and is found, later, sitting on the curb outside, by someone who does not tell her to calm down. The lyrics were written by AI, the music and the voices were generated with ACE-Step, and the pictures with Stable Diffusion XL. The chorus:

Longer out than in
Let it rise, let it go
It’s only panic and it passes
Even when it’s slow
Longer out than in
Feet down on the floor
Name five things that I can see
And breathe out a little more

← All essays